Podcast host: Matt Appleby, HortWeek editor
Guests: Nigel Hewitt-Cooper (Hewitt-Cooper Carnivorous Plants), Matt Soper (Hampshire Carnivorous Plants), Rosie Hardy (Hardy's Cottage Garden Plants), and Justin Van Kessel (CarniFlora, Netherlands).
Producer: Christina Taylor
In this episode, Matt Appleby sits down with four leading growers to discuss the 2027 RHS show rules requiring all plants to be grown 100% peat-free.
While the panel supports reducing peat use in principle, they highlight technical and commercial obstacles that have forced some specialist growers to abandon RHS shows entirely.
As carnivorous plants growers, Hewitt-Cooper, Soper and Van Kessel explain the specific difficulties they find growing peat-free growing media when their plants require inert, nutrient-free environments. They question the conclusions of RHS trials that claim to have found solutions and add that proposed alternatives, like milled sphagnum moss, pose significant commercial hurdles, including rapid drying, pest and disease risks and high costs.
Herbaceous perennial grower Rosie Hardy shares her 17-year journey to peat-free growing. Despite her success, she backs calls for a phased approach: "My problem is that a lot of these nurseries that are exhibiting are small nurseries and they're expecting them to change from something which is a relatively cheap product to something which is much more expensive and therefore it doesn't make economic sense."
Dutch grower Justin Van Kessel adds that many continental growers find the transition financially unviable due to a lack of market premium and fluctuating substrate quality.
They call for properly funded research into viable alternatives to prevent a mass exodus of rare plant exhibitors. Hewitt-Cooper argues for a nuanced approach to rules on peat-reduction or elimination: "We're in a situation whereby we want to succeed in achieving a one size fits all scenario. But as with a lot of things in life, that's just impossible. You can't have that one size fits all solution to this."


